Michelle Monaghan and Carla Gugino looked almost identical wearing purple Tibi dresses, but who wore it best? The dress in question is the wool Tibi City Crepe Sheath Dress. It also comes in a bright, sunny yellow, and features a round scoop neck, cap sleeves, piping detail throughout and a back split at the hem.

Carla first wore the dress in January, while attending the Los Angeles premiere of “The Rite“, starring Anthony Hopkins. She accessorized her look with nude peep-toe heels and a bronze clutch. Michelle recently wore the dress while promoting her film “Source Code” on Good Morning America. She paired the dress with nude platform pumps.

Which lady rocked this Tibi dress hotter?